Living in Lake Mary, FL: What a Home Really Costs (2026)

Leer en español

The short version

  • Lake Mary is in Seminole County.
  • The city tax rate is 3.5895 mills and the county general rate is 5.3751 mills for fiscal year 2025-26 (Florida Department of Revenue).
  • The average homeowners insurance premium in Seminole County was $3,545 a year, with data as of March 31, 2026 (Florida Office of Insurance Regulation).
  • On a $444,000 home, those two tax rates and average insurance come to about $590 a month, before the loan payment. This is an estimate and not the full tax bill.

Where it is

Lake Mary is in northern Seminole County, along Interstate 4 between Longwood and Sanford. Lake Mary Boulevard is its main east-west road, with a large office corridor near the interstate.

What is around

  • A SunRail station on Lake Mary Boulevard
  • Central Park next to City Hall, where the city holds its events
  • The office corridor along Interstate 4 and International Parkway
  • Shops and restaurants at Colonial TownPark

The math on a $444,000 home

Every figure here is an estimate. The county property appraiser and tax collector set and bill the real tax, and a licensed insurance agent gives the real insurance quote.

Step 1. Add the two rates.
5.3751 + 3.5895 = 8.9646 mills. One mill is $1 for every $1,000 of taxable value.

Step 2. Taxable value.
With the typical $50,000 homestead exemption: $444,000 - $50,000 = $394,000.

Step 3. County and city tax.
$394,000 x 8.9646 / 1,000 = about $3,532 a year, or about $294 a month.

Step 4. Insurance.
$3,545 / 12 = about $295 a month. Your home's age, roof and location can move this a lot. Flood insurance is separate.

Step 5. Add them.
$294 + $295 = about $590 a month.

This is low on purpose. School taxes, fire or other special districts and the water management district are added on top, and they change by address, so do not use this number to compare one city with another. HOA and CDD fees are extra. Use the property appraiser's estimator for the full bill on a specific address, and add your loan payment with the monthly cost calculator.

One date to know

Florida voters approved Amendment 3 on November 3, 2026. It raises the homestead exemption on non-school taxes starting January 1, 2027, and it treats people who were not Florida residents on December 31, 2026 differently for their first years. If you are moving here, read the homestead date explained before you set your budget.

Questions buyers ask

What county is Lake Mary in?
Seminole County.

Is there a SunRail station in Lake Mary?
Yes. The Lake Mary station is on the SunRail line.

Where do I check the property tax on a specific address?
With the Seminole County Property Appraiser, which has a tax estimator. Do not rely on the current owner's bill, because the home is reassessed after a sale.

Mayken Giraldo is a real estate sales associate. He is not a lender, attorney, tax adviser or insurance agent. For loan, legal, tax or insurance questions, talk to a licensed professional in that field.

Looking at a home in Lake Mary? Book a buyer consultation or ask what your home is worth, and we will run the full monthly number for that address.

Mayken Giraldo, REALTOR®, The C. Smith Real Estate Group LLC. (929) 239-7663.

Sources

  • Florida Department of Revenue, Table 1, Seminole County, taxes levied for fiscal years 2024-25 and 2025-26: floridarevenue.com
  • Florida Office of Insurance Regulation, Insurer Stability Unit Report, July 2026, average homeowners premiums by county, data as of March 31, 2026: floir.gov
  • Florida Department of Revenue, Informational Bulletin PTO 26-21, "Constitutional Amendment 3", November 5, 2026: floridarevenue.com
  • SunRail, stations and schedules, read November 21, 2026: sunrail.com